Winter sunlight falls across a red-brick home's painted porch, charcoal front door and paired windows, with a red-berried winterberry beside the steps.

Dallastown's Christmas Belongs to the Fire Hall, the Legion and the Churches on Main Street

Who throws Dallastown's Christmas? On Saturday, Nov. 28, the borough lights the tree in front of the American Legion on Main Street, and the lighting and Santa's arrival are scheduled from 6:15 to 6:30 p.m. That's fifteen minutes. Santa visits, crafts and refreshments get a full hour after that, and they happen down the block at the Rescue Fire Co., 50 S. School Pl.

The rest of the season works the same way. Between now and Christmas Day, nearly everything on Dallastown's holiday calendar is hosted by a fire company, a church, a veterans' post or a historical society, at addresses that usually serve other purposes. Those buildings were also the hosts for the season's first event.

Five Buildings Set Up the Season Opener

The 17th annual Christmas in Dallastown, set for Nov. 7, was organized around five main venues: Christ Lutheran Church at 126 W. Main St., Bethlehem Church at 109 E. Main St., SAFER at 50 S. School Pl., the American Legion at 57 W. Main St. and Victoria Villa at 621 E. Main St. The Dallastown Area Historical Society planned holiday activities at its museum, 118 E. Main St.

Most of those addresses come back over the next six weeks. Main Street businesses signed on as well. The event brochure listed Roma's Pizza at 2 E. Main St. with gift-card and slice specials and Sechrist Brothers, Inc. at 32 E. Main St. with a daily special. The places that carry the calendar from here to December, though, are the volunteer buildings.

This is how the borough runs its big events in general. The Dallastown Borough Fall/Winter 2026 newsletter thanks York County Parks, Red Lion Borough, York Excavating and York Township for lending light towers. The same page announces next summer's carnival for Aug. 17 through 21, 2027. A small borough borrows lights from its neighbors and space from its institutions, and the holidays are no exception.

The Fire Company Holds the Longest Stretch

The longest event on the calendar belongs to SAFER, the fire company. Its section of the borough newsletter lists a Christmas Extravaganza running Nov. 20 through Dec. 18. That window opens eight days before the tree lighting and closes a week before Christmas. The same listing includes standing evenings that continue straight through the season:

  • Weekly cash bingo every Friday at Station 1 in Dallastown. Doors open at 5 p.m. and games start at 7 p.m.
  • Bluegrass concerts on Nov. 21 and Dec. 5 at Station 4. Doors open at 5 p.m. and music starts at 7 p.m. The series runs into spring, with dates through March 20.
  • Hall rentals across SAFER locations, booked by calling 717-246-1629. Families planning a December gathering may want to call early.

On Nov. 28 the station also becomes Santa's headquarters. The newsletter calls the location SAFER 13-1 and says every child will get a chance to visit Santa from 6:30 to 7:30 p.m. If your family wants the Santa visit, count on the hour at School Place more than the fifteen minutes on Main Street.

The fire company's newsletter section also includes a seasonal reminder. As chimney fire season approaches, it asks residents to make sure their fireplaces and chimneys are clean.

The Season, Address by Address

Here is the calendar from this Saturday through Christmas Day, with the host for each event. The fire company's Friday bingo runs every week on top of these dates. Volunteer groups and their buildings show up on almost every line.

Date Event Where Host
Sat., Nov. 14 Scouting For Food See borough flyer Listed by the borough
Sat., Nov. 14 Veterans Luncheon 109 E. Main St. Bethlehem Church
Nov. 20 to Dec. 18 Christmas Extravaganza SAFER Fire company
Sat., Nov. 21 Bluegrass concert, 7 p.m. Station 4 Fire company
Sat., Nov. 28 Tree lighting, 6:15 p.m. In front of the American Legion, Main St. Borough
Sat., Nov. 28 Santa party, 6:30 to 7:30 p.m. 50 S. School Pl. Borough at SAFER 13-1
Fri., Dec. 4 Cookies & Cocoa with Santa, tree lighting at 7 p.m. York Township Administrative Building York Township Recreation
Sat., Dec. 5 Cookie Walk, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. 1009 Blymire Road St. John's Blymires UCC
Sat., Dec. 5 Bluegrass concert, 7 p.m. Station 4 Fire company
Sun., Dec. 6 Holiday open house, 1 to 4 p.m. 118 E. Main St. Dallastown Area Historical Society
Sun., Dec. 6 Make-A-Wish Family Celebration 109 E. Main St. Bethlehem Church
Thu., Dec. 24 Christmas Eve services, 4, 7:30 and 10:30 p.m. 109 E. Main St. Bethlehem Church
Fri., Dec. 25 Free Community Christmas Day Meal 109 E. Main St. Bethlehem Church

Two weekends carry most of the load. On Saturday, Dec. 5, the Cookie Walk at St. John's Blymires UCC sells cookies by the pound at $12 a pound, and the bluegrass concert starts at Station 4 that evening. On Sunday, Dec. 6, the historical society at 118 E. Main St. and Bethlehem Church at 109 E. Main St. both have events on the same block of East Main.

The Friday before, York Township's Cookies & Cocoa with Santa runs from 6:30 to 9 p.m. at the York Township Administrative Building. The choir starts at 6:30, and the tree is lit at 7. That gives Dallastown families a second tree lighting six days after their own. York Township also lists a Small Business Saturday Craft Show for Nov. 28, the same day as the borough's tree lighting.

Bethlehem Church Starts and Ends the Season

No single building has more dates on the calendar than Bethlehem Church at 109 E. Main St. It was one of the main venues for Christmas in Dallastown. Its upcoming-events list continues with the Veterans Luncheon on Nov. 14 and the Make-A-Wish Family Celebration on Dec. 6. On Christmas Eve it holds a 4 p.m. family service, a 7:30 p.m. contemporary service and a 10:30 p.m. candlelight service. On Christmas Day it hosts a free community meal.

The same building houses Common Grounds Café. The church's events list in the borough newsletter marks Sept. 9 as the date the café opened for the year. The York Daily Record profiled the café in 2024 as a student-run business. The church posts its schedule on its website and Facebook page.

The Dallastown Lions Club handles a different part of the season. Its newsletter section lists Christmas food baskets and Toys for Tots for neighbors in need, and the contact number is printed in the borough newsletter. The borough has also posted a flyer for Scouting For Food on Nov. 14.

The Museum's Last Open House of the Year

The Dallastown Area Historical Society opens its museum at 118 E. Main St. on the first Sunday of each month from 1 to 4 p.m. Admission is free, and donations are welcome. Sunday, Dec. 6, is listed as the final open house of 2026, with holiday decorations alongside the regular exhibits. The society posts its dates on its website and on the marquee facing Main Street.

That December visit falls in a year when the building itself needs work. In the borough newsletter, the society reports that donations from Give Local York in 2025 and 2026 raised $7,829 toward a roof replacement. Combined with a $30,000 Open Spaces grant, that money makes the project feasible. Unexpected challenges in securing contractor bids have delayed the work, but the society says the plans are going ahead. The museum belongs on the same list as the fire hall and the churches. It keeps its own calendar, lends its space to the borough's big days, and pays for its own upkeep through donations and grants.

Where to Eat Between Stops

Main Street's holiday weekends cover very little distance. From the American Legion at 57 W. Main St. to Bethlehem Church at 109 E. Main St. and the museum at 118 E. Main St. is a short stretch of one street. Roma's Pizza at 2 E. Main St. and Sechrist Brothers at 32 E. Main St. are both in between, and both appear in the Christmas in Dallastown brochure. Santa's party is around the corner at 50 S. School Pl., the same address that hosts the fire company's Friday bingo.

If you're mapping out the season around your own street, our Dallastown neighborhood page has more about the borough. A few miles east, Red Lion, one of the boroughs that lent Dallastown a light tower, runs its own downtown calendar.

At Nicholas Bostic, we keep track of what happens on Dallastown's blocks year-round, from the Legion's tree to the museum's roof fund. If you have questions about your home or your street this season, schedule a consultation and we'll start with what you see from your front porch.

Let’s Talk About What’s Next

Buying or selling real estate is more than a checklist—it’s a major decision. I’m here to help you move forward with confidence, clarity, and care. Let’s connect and build your plan together.

Follow Me on Instagram